Guide · Insurance claims and process

How subsidence claims actually work: a step-by-step guide

What happens after you report cracking to your insurer — investigation, monitoring, repair and the Certificate of Structural Adequacy — from a team with insurer-side claims experience.

Start here

Subsidence is one of the most feared words in home ownership, and one of the least understood insurance processes. Having handled subsidence claims from the insurer’s side, we can tell you the process is more methodical — and usually less catastrophic — than most policyholders expect. Here is how a claim actually unfolds.

Inside a subsidence claim: trial pit, drain camera, level monitoringCutaway of the front corner of a bay-fronted brick semi during a subsidence investigation, its walls broken out in brick steps: the front wall rises to a first-floor window at the corner and the gable wall steps down towards the back. A stepped crack, widening upward, runs from beside the bay to the window sill. A trial pit is open at the front corner, cut in section to show the brick wall bearing on a wider concrete strip footing about 0.9 m below ground, with the spoil heaped on a tarp and a hand auger leaning on it. On the path the inspection chamber is open, its cover on the lawn, and a CCTV drain camera rod runs into it from a reel while a surveyor watches the feed on a tablet; the drain pipe shows in its trench on the cut face. Level-monitoring studs run along the base of the walls. A key notes that a straightforward claim commonly takes 12 to 18 months.061218Typical claim · 12–18 monthsLevelmonitoringTrial pitFoundation depth0.9 mCCTVdrain survey
  • MonitoringLevel monitoring
  • Trial pit
  • Foundation 0.9 mFoundation depth 0.9 m
  • CCTV drain survey
  1. Level monitoring
  2. Trial pit
  3. Foundation depth 0.9 m
  4. CCTV drain survey
Fig. 1 · Subsidence claim in progressIllustrative. Inside a subsidence claim: trial pit, drain camera, level monitoring.
Contents10 sections

Step 1: notification and triage

You notice cracking (or a drain survey, surveyor or builder flags it) and notify your buildings insurer. Subsidence is a standard insured peril in UK buildings policies, usually with a higher excess — commonly £1,000.

The Association of British Insurers suggests contacting your insurer as soon as you suspect subsidence, and lists the kinds of cracking worth reporting: cracks wider than about 3mm (roughly the thickness of a £1 coin), diagonal cracks that are wider at the top than the bottom, and cracks that show both inside and outside the house. Check your policy wording too. Garden walls, patios and drives are often not covered unless they are damaged at the same time as the house.

The insurer’s first job is triage: does the damage pattern actually suggest subsidence? A significant proportion of notifications are closed at this stage because the cracking is thermal, shrinkage or historic movement. That is not the insurer dodging the claim — most cracking genuinely is not subsidence.

What to do: photograph everything with a scale reference and dates before anyone visits. Do not redecorate over the cracks; the evidence matters.

If you have recently changed insurer

Subsidence develops slowly, so it isn’t always obvious which insurer should handle a claim when you’ve switched policies. Insurers that have signed up to the ABI’s domestic subsidence agreement follow it for change-of-insurer claims, and the Financial Ombudsman Service treats its principles as good practice. In outline: if the damage is notified within eight weeks of switching, the previous insurer usually handles it; between eight weeks and a year, the previous and current insurers share the cost; after a year, the current insurer deals with it. When you switch, answer the new insurer’s questions about cracking and subsidence carefully: under the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 you must take reasonable care not to give a misleading answer.

Two special cases: escape of water and coal mining

If the movement was caused by an escape of water, such as a leaking drain or supply pipe, the Financial Ombudsman Service notes that the claim is usually considered first under the escape of water section of the policy. That can change the excess and how the claim is handled.

Damage caused by past coal mining is different again. It isn’t normally dealt with by your home insurer but through the Mining Remediation Authority, which also provides coal mining reports for properties in former mining areas, including much of Yorkshire and the Lancashire coalfield.

Step 2: initial technical inspection

If triage suggests possible subsidence, a surveyor or engineer inspects. They will map the cracking, assess the pattern (diagonal stepping through mortar joints, tapering, inside-outside correspondence), and survey the site: trees and their species, drainage runs, slopes, and the age and construction of the building.

The output is usually one of three views: not subsidence (claim declined, with reasons), subsidence with an obvious cause (move to investigation to confirm), or unclear (investigation needed).

Step 3: investigation

This is where the claim slows down, and where policyholders often lose patience — but it is the most important phase. Typical investigations include:

  • CCTV drainage survey — leaking drains are among the most common and most fixable causes
  • Boreholes or trial pits — establishing soil type, foundation depth and moisture content
  • Root analysis — identifying which vegetation is implicated, and whose
  • Level and crack monitoring — precise measurements repeated over months to establish whether movement is ongoing and whether it is seasonal

Monitoring typically runs six to twelve months, sometimes through a full seasonal cycle. This feels glacial when your wall is cracked, but intervening before the cause is proven wastes money and frequently fails.

Step 4: mitigation — addressing the cause

Once causation is established, the cause is removed or managed:

  • Vegetation — removal or reduction of the implicated trees. Where a neighbour’s or council tree is involved, this can add months of liaison (and occasionally a recovery claim against the tree owner).
  • Drainage — repair or relining of defective drains.
  • Heave risk check — before removing a mature tree on shrinkable clay, the risk of the ground swelling as it rehydrates has to be considered. This is why “just cut the tree down” is not always the first move.

In the majority of claims, mitigation plus a period of confirmed stability is enough. Underpinning is the exception, not the rule — it is required only where the ground cannot be stabilised by removing the cause.

Step 5: repair

Once monitoring confirms the building is stable, repairs are scoped and carried out — typically crack repair, re-pointing, replastering and redecoration. Structural repairs such as partial rebuilding or underpinning are specified by an engineer where genuinely needed.

Check the scope carefully before signing it off. Under-scoped subsidence repairs — hairline “making good” over movement damage that needed stitching or re-building — are a recurring source of disputes and repeat claims.

Step 6: the paperwork that matters

At the end of a properly handled claim you should receive documentation, often including a Certificate of Structural Adequacy (CSA) where structural repairs were completed under professional supervision. Keep everything: the investigation reports, monitoring data, scope of works and completion certificates.

This file is what makes the property saleable and insurable later. A documented, investigated, repaired subsidence history is a manageable thing; an undocumented one is a valuation problem.

Where claims go wrong

From the inside, the same failure points recur:

  1. Causation disputes — “wear and tear”, “settlement” or “pre-existing” declinatures that do not always survive independent scrutiny.
  2. Investigation drift — monitoring that runs on without decisions being made.
  3. Under-scoped repairs — cosmetic fixes for structural damage.
  4. Communication vacuum — months of silence between milestones, leaving policyholders in the dark in a stressful situation.

An independent technical opinion is most valuable at three moments: when a claim is declined on causation grounds, when a repair scope looks thin, and when repairs are complete but you are not confident they are right. That is precisely the gap independent claims consultancy exists to fill — including, where necessary, supporting a Financial Ombudsman Service referral with a proper technical case.

If you disagree with the insurer

Complain to the insurer first, in writing, and keep copies of everything. The insurer normally has eight weeks to send its final response. If you’re unhappy with that response, or eight weeks pass without one, you can refer the complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which is free to use. The Ombudsman will want to see the evidence, and in a subsidence dispute that usually means the technical evidence: the investigation reports, monitoring results and the reasoning behind the insurer’s decision.

An independent report doesn’t change who runs the claim. You stay in charge of it, and the report gives you, or your solicitor, the technical case to put. We don’t notify, negotiate or settle claims for anyone, which are regulated activities; we provide the technical evidence.

The realistic timeline

A straightforward subsidence claim — clear cause, cooperative parties — commonly runs 12 to 18 months from notification to completed repairs. Complex claims run longer. Knowing that at the outset makes the process far less alarming: the pace is a feature of doing it properly, not a sign your insurer has forgotten you.

Further reading: what home insurance usually covers for subsidence, and how long you have to declare it, and whether subsidence devalues a property.

From the survey archive

Cracks in internal finishes.

A long ceiling crack and a crack above a picture rail, from our survey archive. Cracks like these have several possible causes and do not on their own confirm subsidence.

A long irregular crack and lifting finish across an internal ceiling.

Crack and lifting finish across a ceiling

A long ceiling crack with lifting paint along parts of its length.

An irregular crack in the wall finish above a picture rail, beneath a textured ceiling.

Cracking above a picture rail

An irregular crack across the wall finish between the picture rail and ceiling.

Photographs from our survey archive.

Explore the full photograph collection

Survey photograph

Survey archive photograph

Related service

Insurance claims consultancy

Independent expert support for policyholders: reinstatement cost assessments, claim validation, technical evidence suitable for an Ombudsman complaint and post-repair inspection.

About this serviceRequest an insurance claims consultancy quoteOr call 01484 218579

RICS-regulated firm no. 9317773

Places where this matters

Towns on the coalfields.

Each of these town pages sets out the local coal mining history and when to ask for a coal mining report.

Free tools

Check your own property.

All free tools

Sources and further reading

Written by

Mills Building Consultancy

RICS-regulated firm no. 9317773 · Surveyors with RICS and CIOB membership · PCA Qualified Technician for damp and timber

We are an independent surveying and consultancy firm based in Huddersfield, West Yorkshire. Our work draws on combined experience across contracting, field surveying and complex insurance claims for homeowners, contractors, developers and insurers.

Share this guide

A claim under way?

Ask about the house itself.

Send the address and the situation. You will get an honest view on the right service and a fixed quote before committing.

Fixed quote before you commit

We aim to reply within one working day.